Tuesday, October 19, 2010

RESPONSE ON "CENTRE REFUSES FUNDS FOR COLABA TO BANDRA METRORAIL"

LINE III: COLABA TO BANDRA METRORAIL:
Hindustan Times -16th Oct 2010

DNA – 16th Oct, 2010

As expected – it is happening – Mumbaikars will never see the 3rd line of Metro between Colaba to Bandra – Now Centre says ‘No’ to subsidies required for ` 12000 Crores  Project.

It is perplexing that no PPP partner came forward after 1st and 2nd line awarded to Reliance Infra. Although the ridership would be 43% between Bandra /Colaba, on this route, compared to 16% between Bandra / Mankhurd.

Consider the Following equation:
COST OF
3rd LINE
(20 km route)
10km Underground
10km Elevated
@
@
` 600/- Cr./Km.
` 200/- Cr./Km.
` 4000/- Cr.
` 2000/- Cr.
` 8000/- Cr.


` 400 Cr./Km.
COST OF
2 nd LINE
(32 km route)

Fully Elevated



` 11,500/- Cr.

` 360 Cr./Km.

Now let the Citizens decide whether it is justified to spend `11,500 /- Crores.  When the entire project is heading towards bankruptcy OR invest marginally higher amount of ` 40 Cr./Km. which shall be beneficial for the city of Mumbai for next  100 years.


Nitin Killawala: Architect

No comments:

Post a Comment